NPM vs Gulp – Do I need a build javascript system besides npm scripts

#NPM vs Gulp – Do I need a build javascript system besides npm scripts

First when I look at npm vs gulp I was like, well I can do this with npm scripts, why to learn another tool.
So I tried to make it happen with just npm scripts, this worked great until I tried to automatically create
responsive images with imagemagick. This would have required me to write a complete bash script.

Advantage npm script:
– I just write my build steps as shell commands and I am independent of the lifecycle of certain tools like gulp. As the bash script is portable.
– I minimize the tooling I need to learn. No need to install an additional command-line tool to run your build.
– They don’t have the complexity of a full build tool.

Advantage gulp:
– A tool like Gulp gives you the full power of Node and JavaScript.
– They provide consistent APIs optimized for composing build tasks.
– They offer huge ecosystems of plugins for almost anything you can imagine.
– They avoid cross-platform compatibility problems.
– Gulp is javascript and no additional DSL.
– Gulp increases the performance by doing the build steps in parallel.

So I see that gulp is not so much more to learn as I don’t have to learn a tool with it’s own language. So my decision is I use the best tool for the job if it is in java or javascript.

My solution:

  1. I learn gulp and write my build tasks in javascript.
  2. I include gulp in my npm scripts with the following code into my ‘package.json’:
  "scripts": {
    "build:prod": "gulp build --prod",
    "build:dev": "gulp build"

Leave a Reply